Coastal Louisiana song book: Reflections on reviewing the 2012 Master Plan
Bill Dennison ·Over a period of a couple of years, I co-chaired the Science and Engineering Board of the 2012 Master Plan for Coastal Louisiana. The other members of the SEB were the following: Charles “Chip” Groat (co-chair), Greg Baecher, Ed Barbier, Philip Berke, Mark Brinson, Virginia Burkett, Robert “Tony” Dalrymple, Jos Dijkman, Katherine Ewel and Ed Houde, with Robert Twilley serving as the SEB facilitator. Sadly, Mark Brinson passed away following our first meeting. We met in a variety of locations; Baton Rouge, New Orleans and Lafayette, Louisiana. We also conducted a series of webinars prior to our face-to-face meetings. At each of the face-to-face meetings, I generated a song to commemorate the event, which I presented as part of the final summary session. In order to preserve these songs, I present them here in chronological order.
Our initial face-to-face meeting was in December 2010 in Baton Rouge, Louisiana. Robert Twilley, Louisiana State University, served as the SEB organizer and the Coastal Protection and Restoration Authority lead was Steve Mathies, hence the song was titled “Steve and Bobby Twilley”, set to the tune of “Me and Bobby McGee” by Kris Kristofferson:
Steve and Bobby Twilley
Busted flat in Baton Rouge
And Headin’ for the Plan
Feeling pretty talked out in a few days
Bobby put our panel together
To help his Delivery Team
Took us all away to New Orleans
We made our panel comments
To the Delivery Team
And talked it through
While Bobby sang the blues
With those many deadlines keeping time
And Bobby clappin’ hands
We finally covered all the points that we all knew
chorus
Planning’s just another word for nothing else to do
Planning ain’t worth nothing but it’s free
Feeling good was easy Lord
When Bobby sang the blues
Feeling good was good enough for me
Good enough for Steve and Bobby Twilley
From the delta of the Mississippi
To the coastlines of the Chenier
Bobby shared the secrets of the Plan
His team standing beside him, Lord
With everything he done
Every night he kept us from sleeping
Then somewhere near the end, Lord
We let him know what we thought
Looking for the wisdom we hope to find
And we’ll trade all our tomorrows
For a single yesterday
Holding Bobby’s team next to ours.
Our next meeting was held in March 2011 in Lafayette, Louisiana, but I was in Brisbane, Australia for my sabbatical at the International WaterCentre. I stayed up all night due to the time zone differences connected to the meeting via skype and because of this Australian base, my song commemorating the March 2011 meeting was set to the tune of “Waltzing Matilda” by Andrew “Banjo” Patterson and was called “Prioritizin’ Diversions”:
Prioritizin’ Diversions
Once a jolly SEB met in Lafayette
Under the shade of Twilley’s cypress tree,
And they sang as they watched till a vision was set
“You’ll come a-Prioritizin’ Diversions, with me”
chorus
Prioritizin’ Diversions, Prioritizin’ Diversions
“You’ll come a-Prioritizin’ Diversions, with me”
And they sang as they watched where the river runs,
“You’ll come a-Prioritizin’ Diversions, with me”
Bill was ‘Down Under’, half asleep, it certainly did seem
The rest were ‘Up Over’, viewing the Atchafalaya with glee
And they sang as they made suggestions to the Delivery Team
“You’ll come a-Prioritizin’ Diversions, with me”
Up came the water, that Katrina and Rita sent,
Down came four objectives, actually, five, you see
“When’s that jolly river going to give us some sediment?”
“You’ll come a-Prioritizin’ Diversions, with me”
Up jumped the Delivery Team straight into the fray,
“We’ll find the sediment we need, you wait and see”
And a Cajun may be heard if you pass by that way,
“You’ll come a-Prioritizin’ Diversions, with me”
Prioritizin’ Diversions, Prioritizin’ Diversions
“You’ll come a-Prioritizin’ Diversions, with me”
And a Cajun may be heard our where the river runs
“You’ll come a-Prioritizin’ Diversions, with me”
Upon my return from Australia, I contracted whooping cough and as a result, missed the SEB meeting held in Baton Rouge in July 2011. Instead, I made a trip to Baton Rouge in October 2011 to focus on the communication aspects of the 2012 Master Plan. To commemorate this meeting, influenced by whooping cough, I generated “Makin’ Whoopin’” to the tune of “Makin’ Whoopee” by Gus Kahn and Walter Donaldson. The names in the song refer to the following people: Kirk = William “Kirk” Rhinehardt, CPRA; David = David Groves, RAND Corp.; Karim = Karim Belhadjali, CPRA; Natalie = Natalie Peyronnin, CPRA; Kyle = Kyle Graham, CPRA.
Makin’ Whoopin’
Another visit, another time
Another trip is no crime
Another season, another reason
For makin’ whoopin’
A lot of data, some not so nice
Kirk is nervous, he knows the price
Its so killin’ that he’s so willin’
To make whoopin’
Picture a little salt marsh
Down where the Cajuns cling
Picture the same sweet salt marsh
Think what a flood can bring
David’s crunchin’ numbers and doin’ runs
He’s so ambitious he does even more
But don’t forget folks that’s what you get folks
For makin’ whoopin’
Another month or maybe less
What’s this I hear? Well you can’t guess
Karim feels neglected and he’s suspected
Of makin’ whoopin’
Natalie sits waitin’ for data most every night
David doesn’t phone her he doesn't write
He says he’s busy but she says “Is he?”
He’s makin’ whoopin’
The data shows we doesn’t have the money
Only some tens of billions
Some folks are gonna get wet and it’s not funny
Says the feds need to cough up more billions
David says “Now, Kirk, suppose I fail?”
Kyle says Brown and Caldwell will go to jail
You better keep goin’ I think it’s cheaper
Than makin’ whoopin’
You better keep goin’
I know it’s cheaper than makin’ whoopin’.
The next SEB meeting was held in New Orleans in December 2011. The Christmas season provided the impetus for a Christmas carol “O Master Plan” set to the tune of “O Tannenbaum”, German folk song (= “O Christmas Tree”).
O Master Plan
O Master Plan, O Master Plan
How lovely are your modules!
SEB has looked at you closely
You got it right mostly
O Master Plan, O Master Plan
How lovely are your modules!
O Master Plan, O Master Plan
You created the Water Institute
To deal with uncertainties and scenarios
And Kirk’s set of the pants highs and lows
O Master Plan, O Master Plan
Hooray for the Water Institute
O Master Plan, O Master Plan
You gave us no brainers and stinkers
Diversions and wetlands for restoration
With levees and barriers for protection
O Master Plan, O Master Plan
More no brainers and less stinkers
O Master Plan, O Master Plan
We are committed to the coast
With marshes and shrimp trawlers
Allowing Kyle to waste less dollars
O Master Plan, O Master Plan
We are committed to the coast
O Master Plan, O Master Plan
You are Louisiana’s grand idea
That coastal wetlands can be restored
With findings that cannot be ignored
O Master Plan, O Master Plan
You are Louisiana’s grand idea.
The final SEB meeting was held in February 2012 in Baton Rouge, Louisiana and to commemorate this final session, I adapted the Green Day song “Good Riddance (Time of your life)” written by Billie Joe Armstrong. I prefaced this song with the following, “As bad as this song may be, remember it could be worse (e.g., Mickey Mouse Club tune: And now it’s time to say goodbye, to all our friends and family. Em Ay Es, Te Ee Are, Pea El Ay En Twelve. Master Plan. Bobby Jindal! Master Plan. Bobby Jindal! Forever let us build our marshes high, high, high.)”.
Time of Your Life
Another Master Plan
A milestone in the road.
Life grabs you by the wrist;
Directs you where to go.
So make the best of the Plan and don’t turn back.
It’s not perfect but an important step ahead.
chorus
Nature is unpredictable
But in the end it’s right.
We hope you had the time of your life.
But in the end it’s right.
We hope you had the time of your life.
So take the SEB comments
And incorporate them in the Plan
Then take if off the shelf
In good faith and good time.
Tattoos of memories
The Master Plan 2012.
For what it’s worth,
It was worth all the while.
After the 2012 Master Plan passed the Louisiana Legislature in May 2012, I sent through this version of James Brown’s “I got you (I feel good)” to help Kirk Rhinehardt and his Master Plan Delivery Team celebrate:
I Feel Good
Whoa-oa-oa! I feel good, I knew that I would, now
I feel good, I knew that I would, now
So good, so good, I got a Plan
Whoa! I feel nice, like sugar and spice
I feel nice, like sugar and spice
So nice, so nice, I got a Plan
When I hold the Master Plan
I know that I can’t do no wrong
And when I hold the Master Plan
My hard work paid off
And I feel nice, like sugar and spice
I feel nice, like sugar and spice
So nice, so nice, I got a Plan
Whoa! I feel good, I knew that I would, now
I feel good, I knew that I would
So good, so good, I got a Plan
So good, so good, I got a Plan.
About the author
Bill Dennison
Dr. Bill Dennison is a Professor of Marine Science and Interim President at the University of Maryland Center for Environmental Science (UMCES).